Comments on: Tamil vs. Sanskrit, or Indian ‘official classical languages’, and the first tongue in India (AKA. Indus Valley Civilization language) http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/ Proto-Indo-European Language, Indo-European Languages & European Union Language Policy Fri, 10 Feb 2012 01:49:42 +0000 hourly 1 By: Sam Joshua http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/comment-page-1/#comment-15231 Sam Joshua Sun, 22 Jan 2012 15:35:06 +0000 http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/17/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/#comment-15231 Sir, Please note Tamil had reached the classical status long back. Because of Aryan majority, Sanskrit had to be given Classical status, by reducing age (years) because of which few other languages also had to be accommodated because of equality to Sanskrit. Tamil is already occupied a seat in World's classical status, and every Indians should be proud of it. Sir, Please note Tamil had reached the classical status long back. Because of Aryan majority, Sanskrit had to be given Classical status, by reducing age (years) because of which few other languages also had to be accommodated because of equality to Sanskrit. Tamil is already occupied a seat in World’s classical status, and every Indians should be proud of it.

]]> By: Senthil Kumar http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/comment-page-1/#comment-12081 Senthil Kumar Tue, 22 Nov 2011 11:19:44 +0000 http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/17/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/#comment-12081 Vadavengadam muthal therkey kumari varai TamiZl kurum nal ulagam annaivarukum en muthalkan vanakathai theruvikiren. Tamizl thonmaiya samakritham thonmaiya endru vinavinal Tamizley thonmai endru kuruven!. Enadthu Tamizl nanbar thiru vignesh avargal kuriapadi Kalthondra manthodra kalathil thondria mutha kudi Tamizl kudi. ithan unmaiyana vilakam yathu enil: ulaga mozhlikal thangalukul oru ilakanam vaguthu iradha kalathil adhu ezhluthu ilakanam ayinum sol ilakanam ayinum athruku munpey tamizl mozhli thanaku endrum sirapana ilakanathaiyum ilakiathaiyum thtruvithathu. Agayal than Tamizl mozhliyai nam kalthondra manthodra kalathil thodria mutha kudi endrum alaikirom. Tamizl endrathin thiripadu Tam il endru arutham athavathu angilathil sollavendum endral "One's Self" language. Tamizlin sirapirku oru eduthukathu ak endru kura padum ayutha ezhluthu Tamizl mozhli thavara ulaga mozhligal ethilum kanapadatha oru ariya ezhluthu. Ak in thiripadu adi puli irandum agavazhlkai puravalkai kuripiduvathu mel puli sanyasathai kuripiduvathu. Adthavathu Agathyaum purathayium oruvan kandanthal sanyasathai adayalam. Sanyasaithai adaithal irai nilai peralam. idhu pondra unarvumika ezhluthukal tamizlilum thonmai endrum poi paraisatrum samskridha mozhliku illai. Idhu pondru kodikanakana utharanangal kuralam tamizlin thonmayi mupai patri. Vazlka Tamizl Valarka Tamizl Velga Tamizl Inam Marapu. Vadavengadam muthal therkey kumari varai TamiZl kurum nal ulagam annaivarukum en muthalkan vanakathai theruvikiren. Tamizl thonmaiya samakritham thonmaiya endru vinavinal Tamizley thonmai endru kuruven!. Enadthu Tamizl nanbar thiru vignesh avargal kuriapadi Kalthondra manthodra kalathil thondria mutha kudi Tamizl kudi. ithan unmaiyana vilakam yathu enil: ulaga mozhlikal thangalukul oru ilakanam vaguthu iradha kalathil adhu ezhluthu ilakanam ayinum sol ilakanam ayinum athruku munpey tamizl mozhli thanaku endrum sirapana ilakanathaiyum ilakiathaiyum thtruvithathu. Agayal than Tamizl mozhliyai nam kalthondra manthodra kalathil thodria mutha kudi endrum alaikirom. Tamizl endrathin thiripadu Tam il endru arutham athavathu angilathil sollavendum endral “One’s Self” language. Tamizlin sirapirku oru eduthukathu ak endru kura padum ayutha ezhluthu Tamizl mozhli thavara ulaga mozhligal ethilum kanapadatha oru ariya ezhluthu. Ak in thiripadu adi puli irandum agavazhlkai puravalkai kuripiduvathu mel puli sanyasathai kuripiduvathu. Adthavathu Agathyaum purathayium oruvan kandanthal sanyasathai adayalam. Sanyasaithai adaithal irai nilai peralam. idhu pondra unarvumika ezhluthukal tamizlilum thonmai endrum poi paraisatrum samskridha mozhliku illai. Idhu pondru kodikanakana utharanangal kuralam tamizlin thonmayi mupai patri. Vazlka Tamizl Valarka Tamizl Velga Tamizl Inam Marapu.

]]> By: rajasekar http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/comment-page-1/#comment-11493 rajasekar Wed, 02 Nov 2011 09:45:55 +0000 http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/17/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/#comment-11493 dont hate other languages. we dont know the clear history of both tamil and sanskrit. first you try to develope your mother tongue and do something better for your mother tongue . dont hate other languages. we dont know the clear history of both tamil and sanskrit. first you try to develope your mother tongue and do something better for your mother tongue .

]]> By: Arunan http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/comment-page-1/#comment-10932 Arunan Wed, 21 Sep 2011 14:12:43 +0000 http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/17/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/#comment-10932 In India everything will become Sanskrit, Every word will be there in Sanskrit, There are hundreds of Sanskrit words for a single object, and people calling that as a single language itself is a joke. All Indian dead languages were conveniently called with a name Sanskrit. As a language it was never spoken by the commoners, Twisted sounds of then spoken languages were used as Mantras to cheat people by some elites. Now you should start studying Sanskrit properly i am sure you would end up in Mental hospital within a year. Regarding Tamil its also not so pure, As per my understanding it has more connection with European languages than other North Indian languages equal to its age, may be due to the area's trade connection with the Romans through sea. In India everything will become Sanskrit, Every word will be there in Sanskrit, There are hundreds of Sanskrit words for a single object, and people calling that as a single language itself is a joke. All Indian dead languages were conveniently called with a name Sanskrit. As a language it was never spoken by the commoners, Twisted sounds of then spoken languages were used as Mantras to cheat people by some elites. Now you should start studying Sanskrit properly i am sure you would end up in Mental hospital within a year.
Regarding Tamil its also not so pure, As per my understanding it has more connection with European languages than other North Indian languages equal to its age, may be due to the area’s trade connection with the Romans through sea.

]]> By: Vijay http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/comment-page-1/#comment-10547 Vijay Thu, 18 Aug 2011 10:48:19 +0000 http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/17/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/#comment-10547 Some proofs would have been appreciated here, but none the less a very interesting topic and nice views/theories. But still I think the question "which language is older, Sanskrit or Tamil" remains unanswered and I think will remain unanswered as there are no pakka proofs... Some proofs would have been appreciated here, but none the less a very interesting topic and nice views/theories.

But still I think the question “which language is older, Sanskrit or Tamil” remains unanswered and I think will remain unanswered as there are no pakka proofs…

]]> By: louboutin http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/comment-page-1/#comment-4931 louboutin Fri, 26 Nov 2010 07:50:39 +0000 http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/17/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/#comment-4931 I was looking for an automatical translation wordpress plugin and i found your plugin. I am going to try it on my blog. Thank you. I was looking for an automatical translation wordpress plugin and i found your plugin. I am going to try it on my blog. Thank you.

]]> By: keerthi http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/comment-page-1/#comment-4515 keerthi Fri, 29 Oct 2010 16:27:42 +0000 http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/17/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/#comment-4515 I am very proud to be in Tamil Nadu. Tamil is the most oldest launguage in the world as like latin, herbew, sanskrit etc,. this is being approved by US.... Tamil vazhga I am very proud to be in Tamil Nadu. Tamil is the most oldest launguage in the world as like latin, herbew, sanskrit etc,. this is being approved by US…. Tamil vazhga

]]> By: ekdesiladki http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/comment-page-1/#comment-3757 ekdesiladki Thu, 16 Sep 2010 14:16:15 +0000 http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/17/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/#comment-3757 It's impossible a language like sanskrit used by "elites" could lose all their native speakers. Sankrit was probably mother tongue to NO BODY. Just like languages like Java, c++, etc can't be mother tongue to anyone but created with some purpose. Sanskrit is just a language developed by "elite" dravidians/ancient Indians to utter prayers and preserve culture. Since, Tamil has influeced sanskrit's syntax, speakers/creators of both the languages should be same. It’s impossible a language like sanskrit used by “elites” could lose all their native speakers. Sankrit was probably mother tongue to NO BODY. Just like languages like Java, c++, etc can’t be mother tongue to anyone but created with some purpose.

Sanskrit is just a language developed by “elite” dravidians/ancient Indians to utter prayers and preserve culture. Since, Tamil has influeced sanskrit’s syntax, speakers/creators of both the languages should be same.

]]> By: vignesh http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/comment-page-1/#comment-3756 vignesh Thu, 16 Sep 2010 13:57:39 +0000 http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/17/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/#comment-3756 Hi to everyone.....I saw every ones discussion..I say tamil is the oldest bcoz the world's ancient human's DNA's is found in India only in TamilNadu's villages and he who carries that DNA is only a tamilian.So Tamil is the oldest language and me too say <strong>“Kal thontra maan thontra kalathie muun thontrea muutha kudi engal tamil kudi”</strong> Hi to everyone…..I saw every ones discussion..I say tamil is the oldest bcoz the world’s ancient human’s DNA’s is found in India only in TamilNadu’s villages and he who carries that DNA is only a tamilian.So Tamil is the oldest language and me too say “Kal thontra maan thontra kalathie muun thontrea muutha kudi engal tamil kudi”

]]> By: Rohan.s http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/comment-page-1/#comment-3657 Rohan.s Fri, 03 Sep 2010 05:20:22 +0000 http://carlosquiles.com/indo-european-language-blog/2007/08/17/tamil-vs-sanskrit-or-indian-official-classical-languages-and-the-first-tongue-in-india-aka-indus-valley-civilization-language/#comment-3657 I respect both the language equal. But we have to protect tamil since one of the oldest language is dead already.Though many people say there is no longer history for tamil ,6o percent of archeology found in tamil(magic).So we should learn to respect Tamil as it is an oldest language present in this modern world.God's sanskirit & great Tamil. I respect both the language equal. But we have to protect tamil since one of the oldest language is dead already.Though many people say there is no longer history for tamil ,6o percent of archeology found in tamil(magic).So we should learn to respect Tamil as it is an oldest language present in this modern world.God’s sanskirit & great Tamil.

]]>